Keeping It Real Podcast: Balancing Power - How U.S. Trade Law and Courts Shape Economic Policy

In Season 5, Episode 16 of Keeping it Real with Dr. Kuehl, ASA Chief Economist Dr. Chris Kuehl offers a concise yet insightful economic update on the current complexities surrounding U.S. trade laws, tariffs, and the legal framework that governs them. In just over eight minutes, Dr. Kuehl breaks down how the U.S. legal system—designed as a check on executive power—plays a vital role in interpreting and sometimes challenging trade-related decisions. He explains that while presidential authority can initiate trade actions under specific laws like Sections 122, 301, and 338 of the Trade Act, those decisions can be contested through the court system, reinforcing the balance of power.
 

One of the key points Dr. Kuehl raises is the appealability of court decisions and the limits of presidential powers. The U.S. courts are not just advisory bodies—they are enforceable institutions whose rulings shape national and federal trade policy. While presidents may act quickly under emergency declarations or perceived threats to national security, these actions are subject to legal scrutiny and potential pushback. Courts determine whether such emergencies are legitimate or simply political maneuvers, and they can overturn or restrict actions that overstep legal boundaries.
 

Dr. Kuehl also explores the broader consequences of trade uncertainty on the business community. As trade disputes drag on and the legal landscape remains murky, many businesses are left in a state of confusion. With tariffs potentially rising and their duration unclear, companies are struggling to plan ahead. Dr. Kuehl notes that while some businesses are attempting to adapt through strategic sourcing and pricing adjustments, others remain paralyzed, unsure of what policies will stick and how courts will rule in the coming months.
 

The episode concludes with a look at market sentiment, which reflects a mix of caution and frustration. Dr. Kuehl emphasizes that the unpredictability of legal responses and presidential actions around trade policies has created a volatile environment. While courts provide a path for stability and accountability, they move slowly compared to the fast pace of executive decisions. As these issues continue to unfold, the business sector is watching closely, hoping for clarity but bracing for more turbulence ahead.
 

LISTEN NOW